Discussion about this post

User's avatar
CynthiaW's avatar

Good morning, everyone. Son F is up and moaning, because I opened the door and turned the light on, and his roomie, Vlad, griped at him. His friend is coming to get him at 8:00.

Expand full comment
CynthiaW's avatar

It doesn't look as though the Mothership is going to have a religion article this morning, so I'll offer some Sunday content here at the interwebs' leading publication.

Bishop Michael Martin of the Diocese of Charlotte announced this week that the Diocese will have a single, dedicated location for the celebration of the "Traditional Latin Mass," a form of liturgy superseded by the reforms following the Second Vatican Council. It's important to note that the "TLM" is a whole liturgical complex, including having its own calendar, not simply holding Mass in the Latin language. A priest can celebrate Mass in Latin any time, if he has the language skill, just as he can celebrate Mass in English, Spanish, Vietnamese, or Polish, depending on the needs of congregants under his care.

https://catholicnewsherald.com/90-news/local/11679-latin-mass

The changes to the rules for the TLM were promulgated by Pope Francis in 2021, and the Diocese of Charlotte did a "transitional" compliance in 2023. Our now-retired Bishop Jugis was very ill at this point, so I expect the Vatican-approved delay was partly because he simply didn't have the energy to work on the real estate issue. It may also have partly been in sympathy with the spirit of staying in the past. I know quite a few of the TLM adherents, at least casually, and I know Bishop Jugis and some of his functionaries were close with them. But that is neither here nor there.

There is much wailing and gnashing going on among this cohort, including claims that the "Mass of the Ages" is being "suppressed" or "cancelled," as well as petitions going up the chain toward Rome. I sympathize with the people to some extent. If there had been an instruction from the Vatican or the Bishop that all services were to be in Latin, or that we couldn't have any in Spanish, or "no guitars," or something else that substantially impacted our experience of the liturgy, I'd be upset. However, one thing about being Catholic is accepting that the hierarchy has the authority to make these decisions.

In my opinion, the TLM "community" is effectively a separatist church, declaring themselves to be the True Catholics, literally "more Catholic than the Pope." Another word for that is "Protestant." It's ironic that the facility the Diocese has purchased and is renovating for their use was formerly used by a Protestant congregation. The TLM spokespeople find this scandalous, but I think it's spot-on.

Expand full comment
83 more comments...

No posts